The American Idol stage is gearing up for a major transformation in 2025, as Carrie Underwood steps in as a judge, taking over for Katy Perry, who departs after seven seasons. However, the decision has sparked mixed reactions among fans.
At 40, Perry has voiced her support for Underwood, emphasizing that no one is more fitting for the role than the season 4 champion herself. “She was born on that show. I think she knows how to steer it,” Perry shared with People. “She actually truly knows what it feels like to be in their shoes.”
Season 23 of American Idol: A New Era Begins
With season 23 of American Idol set to premiere on March 9, 2025, fans are eager to see how the transition unfolds, how audiences are reacting, and what the future holds for both Carrie Underwood and Katy Perry.
A Full-Circle Moment for Carrie Underwood
For Carrie Underwood, 41, joining American Idol as a judge is more than just a new role—it’s a homecoming. After winning the competition in 2005, she skyrocketed to fame, becoming one of the most successful country artists of all time. With over 85 million records sold worldwide, eight Grammy Awards, and even a Las Vegas residency, her career is a testament to what Idol can do for aspiring musicians.
Underwood’s addition to the judging panel, alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, feels like a natural fit. Having been in the contestants’ shoes, she deeply understands the emotional journey they experience.
In a recently released season 23 trailer, Underwood is seen getting emotional while offering heartfelt encouragement to a contestant, saying: “Even though this was about your son, every person can fill in that memory.” The clip also captures her wiping away tears as Richie and Bryan console her, highlighting her deep connection to the competition and its hopefuls.
Carrie Underwood Joins American Idol: A Welcome Change or a Risky Move?
While Carrie Underwood’s authenticity and relatability have won over some fans, others are not as enthusiastic—largely due to recent political controversy.
The Political Backlash: A Divided Fanbase
Underwood’s decision to perform at President Donald Trump’s second inauguration earlier this month has sparked significant backlash. Many longtime American Idol viewers have taken to social media, vowing to boycott the show due to her involvement.
One disappointed fan shared:
💬 “I’ve watched every season since 2002, but I can’t support this anymore. I won’t be tuning in.”
On the flip side, others are more excited than ever, with some stating that her addition to the judging panel has encouraged them to watch for the first time.
💬 “I’ve never watched Idol before, but now that Carrie Underwood is a judge, I’m all in!”
Given today’s politically charged climate, this divide isn’t surprising. However, American Idol’s producers remain confident that Underwood’s star power will keep ratings strong.
Katy Perry’s Exit: What’s Next for Her?
As Underwood steps in, Katy Perry is stepping away. After seven successful seasons, Perry decided to leave American Idol to focus on her music career and personal life.
“I just wanted to make space for other things,” Perry told Entertainment Tonight in April 2024—and she has certainly been busy since.
🎵 Released her seventh studio album, 143, in late 2024.
🌍 Kicking off a world tour in April 2025.
💰 Her net worth, estimated at $350 million, is expected to grow even more with this tour.
👶 Balancing music, motherhood, and business ventures.
Perry, who shares 4-year-old daughter Daisy Dove Bloom with fiancé Orlando Bloom, has expressed a desire to spend more time with family while still pursuing her passion for music.
For those who will miss her presence on Idol, don’t worry—she’ll still be in the spotlight, just in a different way.
What This Means for American Idol
With Perry gone and Underwood stepping in, American Idol is entering a new chapter. But will this transition be a success?
Potential Pros of Carrie Underwood as a Judge:
✅ Firsthand Experience – She’s been in the contestants’ shoes and understands the pressure.
✅ Strong Fanbase – Her popularity could attract new viewers and boost ratings.
✅ Emotional Depth – Her deep connection to the show adds authenticity to her critiques.
Potential Cons:
❌ Political Controversy – Her recent involvement in Trump’s inauguration could alienate some viewers.
❌ Different Energy – Her softer personality may not match Perry’s lively and playful presence.
❌ Missed Chemistry – Fans may miss the fun banter between Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie.
Still, fresh energy isn’t always a bad thing. With American Idol reaching its 23rd season, change might be exactly what it needs to stay relevant.
The Verdict: Will Fans Stick Around?
Whether fans love or hate this change, Carrie Underwood’s American Idol debut is shaping up to be one of 2025’s biggest TV moments. While some are boycotting, others are tuning in for the first time just to see her.
The real test comes on March 9, when the season premiere airs at 8 p.m. ET on ABC. Will audiences embrace the change, or will Perry’s absence leave an unfillable void?
One thing is certain—season 23 of American Idol will be one for the books.
